Miranda Moore, 2012 Valley View Road, stated the neighbors had not been consulted or
communicated with from the beginning nor when the Planning and Zoning Commission
had suggested it, explained they had been told to take solace with the fact the agent
lived next door and would fix problems promptly when notified, and noted they did not feel
that would happen due to the lack of communication and falsehoods thus far.
Maris Ashby, 2003 Valley View Road, commented that this short-term rental did not give
anything meaningful back to the neighborhood, noted it would take
a
beautiful
single-family home out of the small residential area where families lived, built
relationships, and put down roots, take their privacy as the neighborhood did not have
privacy fences and was not built for separation, and take away the ease of letting children
play in the front yards and the cul-de-sac when that was the only option as the back
yards were steep, explained this corridor was not designed to absorb rotating guests and
there were already access and parking issues, which the City had helped manage during
holidays and big events, reiterated that there was not a benefit to the neighborhood,
pointed out that the lack of communication from the owners and agent was not a missed
courtesy as it was about accountability and trust and there was not any assurance that
they would be proactive or reactive going forward.
Russell Boyt, indicated he was representing the owners, felt there were a lot of mistruths,
stated he and the owners had met with and provided contact information to a large group
of homeowners after the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting and he had spoken to
the Kalinkos, who were next to the subject property, to try to address their concerns,
pointed out a neighborhood meeting had been held and neither he nor his wife had been
invited, explained the home was purchased by Jon and Laurie Gehrke in September of
2025 after it had been on the market for 120 days, provided examples of how the
Gehrke’s were deeply rooted in the Columbia community, noted the home was purchased
for the personal enjoyment of Gehrke’s as they made several trips to Columbia annually
and planned to retire here, believed it had the potential as a short-term rental due to its
proximity to the University and the hospitals, commented that the driveway had two
recognized parking spaces with room for another and a third space would be added next
week, emphasized that he lived next door and would handle the day-to-day scheduling,
maintenance, and concerns, and stated there would not be any on-street parking even
though the main section of Valley View was 31 feet in width, which was enough for cars
to be parked on both sides and wider than the streets in newer subdivisions, such as Old
Hawthorne and The Brooks.
Laurie Gehrke, a resident of Oskaloosa, Iowa, and owner of 2002 Valley View Road with
her husband, noted she had been a nurse for 45 years with the last 21 years as a
pediatric flight nurse, stated it was not their intent to endanger the children of the
neighborhood as they had raised six children on a cul-de-sac as well, explained she and
her husband wanted to use the property as did their now adult children, commented that
if they could not use it as a short-term rental, they would use it as a long-term rental and
be forced to stay in hotels again when coming to Columbia, indicated they had spoken to
and exchanged numbers with the neighbors after the Planning and Zoning Commission
meeting, and pointed out they had not been able to attend the meeting on May 4 due to
her husband’s surgical complications.
Susan Maze, a First Ward resident, commented that the short-term rental ordinance
included neighborhood protections, such as short-term rentals not being within 300 feet of
one another, neighbors having a say, and the establishment of an 800 number to report
violations after hours because currently it was impossible to register a complaint after
5:00 p.m. without
a police report even with video evidence, noted that since the
establishment of the short-term rental ordinance, she had noticed that neighborhood
opposition, affordable housing, the concentration of short-term rentals, and factual
discrepancies did not matter, and felt the ordinance that many had worked hard on did
nothing to protect them from the issues.
Jon Gehrke stated he felt bad for creating this situation in a sense as they were not trying
to negatively affect the neighborhood, explained they were trying to enhance the
neighborhood and had put a lot of money in and around the house, noted they were
hoping to be there soon on a full-time basis, but could not say when that would happen,