City of Columbia, Missouri  
Meeting Minutes  
Finance Advisory and Audit Committee  
Conference Rooms  
1A & 1B  
Monday, September 16, 2024  
1:00 PM  
Columbia City Hall  
701 E. Broadway  
I. CALL TO ORDER  
Randy Minchew and Brian Toohey were sworn in.  
Oropallo called the meeting to order at approximately 1:00p.  
Attending from City of Columbia's Finance Department was Matthew Lue, James  
McDonald, Deep Debnath, Shane Edwards, and Clarissa English  
Community Attendees included Jim Windsor and Mike Murphy  
4 - Maria Oropallo, Thomas Richards, Randy Minchew and Brian Toohey  
Present:  
Absent:  
3 - Kristian Bloom, Karilee Gruenberg and Chris Prestigiacomo  
II. INTRODUCTIONS  
No introductions were made.  
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA  
Richards motioned to approve the agenda, Minchew seconded; motion carries  
unanimously.  
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES  
Minchew motioned to approve the minutes, Richards seconded; motion carries  
unanimously.  
V. OLD BUSINESS  
No discussion.  
No discussion.  
Lue explained the FY25 Budget will be voted on by Council at that night’s meeting. He  
reviewed high dollar amendments, including:  
1. Vehicles $4 million dollars with $1.4 million for new police cars,  
2. Overall, the new budget total of $563M is a 3% from last year  
3. Personnel costs, which were raised by 3.5% to bring City employees on par with the  
CPI This also included 30 new positions, more than one third going to public safety.  
Minchew commented that the City was at 300 vacancies at the beginning of the year, but  
currently the City is at 100 vacancies.  
Richards spoke of comparing the proposed FY25 budget to last year’s budget, and asked  
if the City has reconciled back to actual. He also asked if the 30 new positions were in  
addition to former vacancy numbers. Lue responded they were new positions, bringing the  
100 vacancies to 130.  
Richards asked if positions were eliminated. He also commented that these discussions  
go back to clarifying the committee’s purpose to advise the Council without this  
information. Richards added that a clear presentation of the numbers was needed or it  
would impact trust.  
Lue responded that the Police had combined positions, dropped a position, and added a  
different one. He added that Human Resources publishes a reconciliation report on how  
many positions the City actually has, vs. how many are new/filled.  
Oropallo asked when this report will be available. Lue responded end of October,  
possibly. Oropallo responded the timing was a problem, as the report is issued after the  
new budget is approved.  
Minchew mentioned that he has heard the public wants to see and understand critical  
information, and people say the City is not being transparent. Debnath explained how  
staff provides information, accessible on the City’s website.  
Richards asked what percentage of the budget was salaries and benefits, Lue responded  
60% of budget, adding that personnel costs and how it affects the budget is often  
discussed.  
Not presented due to lack of quorum during time of presentation.  
VI. NEW BUSINESS  
Not Presented due to lack of quorum during time of presentation.  
Oropallo offered an explanation of why the meetings were held on the second  
Council Monday that allowed for greater access to the Council Agenda and  
ability to advise Council on fiscal matters.  
Minchew made a motion for the current Finance Advisory and Audit Committee  
meeting schedule to remain unchanged, Richards seconded; motion carries  
unanimously.  
VII. GENERAL COMMENTS BY PUBLIC, MEMBERS AND STAFF  
None.  
VIII. NEXT MEETING DATE  
October 21, 2024  
IX. ADJOURNMENT  
At 1:50 pm, Toohey left the meeting.  
Meeting adjourned at 1:50pm due to loss of quorum.