Village Arts District Board, stated this discussion had started at least 20 years ago,
noted this was an amazing opportunity for the downtown area, explained this was a
special location that required special considerations and development opportunities,
understood the Parks and Recreation Department staff had worked hard to ensure the
development of the best park for downtown, and noted the North Village Arts District was
thrilled about the opportunities the park would provide for more programming as well as
the expansion of existing programming.
The Council made comments.
B132-26 was given third reading by the City Clerk with the vote recorded as
follows: VOTING YES: CARROLL, ELWOOD, SAMPLE, HARTMAN, PETERS,
BUFFALOE. VOTING NO: NO ONE. ABSENT: FOSTER. Bill declared enacted,
reading as follows:
B123-26
Granting the issuance of a conditional use permit to Dirk Mai and Aylya
Marzolf to allow the operation of a short-term rental on property located at
802 N. Sixth Street; providing a severability clause (Case No.107-2026).
The bill was given second reading by the City Clerk.
Community Development Director Clint Smith provided a staff report, and responded to
Council questions and comments.
Aylya Marzolf, owner of 802 N. Sixth Street, explained she and her husband had been
living in the property and renovating it when her husband was offered a job in Los Angeles
that they could not pass up and their solution had been to turn it into a short -term rental,
which it had been for two years, noted her family of four visited Columbia multiple times
per year and for months at a time, which they would not be able to do otherwise since
they could not stay at a hotel or at her sister’s for weeks at a time, commented that the
notices regarding the short-term rental regulations had been going to the Sixth Street
address instead of their Los Angeles address, which had since been remedied, felt the
short-term rental process had been confusing and difficult to navigate, understood there
was a concern of short-term rentals limiting affordable housing, pointed out there were 13
properties for sale and more than 10 for rent in the neighborhood, indicated they took
great care in terms of their guests by looking at reviews, ratings, and asking why they
were coming to Columbia, believed their home was an asset to Columbia as a place for
guests to stay while spending money at local restaurants, bars, stores, music venues,
etc. rather than it being empty on the market, stated there had not been any complaints
from the neighbors, reiterated they cared about the neighborhood and Columbia, and
asked that they be allowed to continue to operate.
Susan Maze, a First Ward resident, commented that she had not received notification of
this request even though she lived in the house on the top corner of the slide that was
being displayed, emphasized that there was not a way to register a complaint with the
Housing and Neighborhood Services Department about housing issues, such as noise,
even with video evidence without a police report, which could not be obtained if the police
did not show up, explained she knew this because she had tried on several occasions
before finally giving up, noted the person who had spoken in favor of this request was a
landlord who did not live in the neighborhood, pointed out this would be the eighth
licensed short-term rental in the North Central neighborhood if approved, pointed out North
Central was an affordable neighborhood as a four bedroom home two doors down from her
had just been put up for sale for $199,000, understood some of the homes the prior
speaker had referred to as still being on the market had income guidelines along with a
good credit rating, which was difficult to accomplish when making late payments due not
making much money, and stated short-term rentals were causing major issues around
affordable housing.
Pat Fowler a resident of Sixth Street, provided a handout with the addresses of other
short-term rentals in the neighborhood, including some that had been administratively
approved, explained she had not received notice of this request either, and read a
statement from her neighbor, Mara Aruguete, who lived immediately across the street
from this property, which indicated she was opposed to this short-term license
application due to the disruption of community stability, the negative impact on